
I was at a dinner party on Saturday night and one of the main topics of conversation was Rendell's attention grabbing 'rescue' mission to Haiti.
Plenty of questions were raised. The most fundamental was: Who decided that it was legal and who gets those kids? Some asked "How is it Rendell's role to facilitate international matters?
Overall folks were incredulous that Rendell was involved and that he pulled it off without any hard core investigation by anyone. Except maybe Anderson Cooper.
News this week is loaded with questions about the baby biz. About the meaning of "orphanage" and journalists are examining the ethics of 'rescuing' babies in times of crises.
Here's a juicy bit from another blog: in my earlier post I suggested that the overwhelming demands to move children out of Haiti for adoption elsewhere were in a way a twisted expression of American consumerism. I wrote, “It…. matches the consumerist mindset, in which by simply acquiring the right things – even your very own “orphan” – your situation, and that of the world, will improve.”
I didn’t quite expect that in little more than 24 hours, events, driven by a founder of a company that sells consumer products online, would serve to drive home that point and others I was trying to make. It’s the mythology of international adoption that is driving American prospective adopters, politicians and Christian organizations to organize the exporting of Haitian children to the United States, amid calls for legislation to simplify adoptions for prospective adopters by creating a dedicated office for it at the State Department.
Central to those calls was the demand for rapid visa approvals from the State Department. Seldom heard from this crowd was any mention that the Haitians, assisted by aid organizations, might have some interest in monitoring, or even restricting completely, the flow of unaccompanied children out of their country, making the issue of the State Department’s speed rather moot.
Most American churchgoing suburbanites are unable to drop everything, get on a plane and run off to Haiti and see if they can, for themselves, run their own version of what some of us are calling “Rendell’s Raid,” in which the governor of Pennsylvania flew to Haiti, twisted the arms of various politicians, put pressure on what was left of the Haitian government, and finally, packed more than 50 of Haiti’s children on a U.S. military plane. But inevitably, someone with some means and willing accomplices, if not connections, would actually make such an attempt – this time, ending with ten Americans being arrested by Haitian police. At this writing it’s very likely that they’re sitting in jail cells in Port-au-Prince.
There is
a story that Rendell's posse stole the rescue show from another politician who did all the leg work. There are lots of 'thoughts' on
Ed's move here in the comments section.
2/5, UPDATE: Mia Farrow's take on the issue appears enlightened to me."Farrow, who herself has adopted 11 children, says offering parents a better life for their children elsewhere is "completely unacceptable and immoral.""